This post was written in 2015 but I decided to dust it off – most of it is relevant today.
As fixed income returns have been compressing, it has become harder and harder for banks for find investments which have no capital charge under Basel III and have a positive enough yield to cover the expenses a bank has with enough left over to pay the depositor. Receiving zero on deposits – which are unsecured loans – has become standard and one has to only look at Skatbank in Germany to find negative deposit rates i. They charge ¼% on deposits, other European banks are charging fees to “park money” and this trend is spreading, especially for larger, commercial accounts ii. Australia is taking it one step further – the government announced plans to tax deposits.iii
The concept that cash is, on a risk adjusted basis, a negative carry asset may be clearer if you think of bank deposits like renting a safety deposit box for a fee and putting money in it. In effect that’s what a bank deposit is except that the imaginary safe has a door in the back and the bank has the right to take the money out at will and invest it as it sees fit in risky assets so it can pay the deposit box fee. Ironically, a bank does everything but safe keep your money – it takes it and puts it at risk to earn a return. The risks are just not very visible to the average depositor but are real nevertheless.
As money in the form of cash can leave the banking system, cash is potentially destabilizing both to banks and to the banking system. So it is no surprise that HSBC is discontinuing safety deposit boxes.iv JPM Chase is starting to prohibit customers from storing cash in their safe deposit boxes as well.v
A more efficient way to limit the role of cash however is to legislate limits. France, a few days ago announced restrictions where French nationals will be limited to 1000 € cash per financial transaction.vi France is not unique in this, it is simply following in the footsteps of other nationsvii, viii. The stated reason for limiting the supply of cash is usually quite reasonable: fighting terrorism, tax evasion, drugs etc. but the side effect is that less and less money can leave the financial system even if it wanted to. This shifts the balance of power between financial institutions that can create money and individuals and businesses who can’t. Taking it a step further Willem Buiter of Citi Bank is the most recent economist to suggest that cash should be abolished completelyix, leaving no option but having to trust financial institutions to put depositor’s interests first.
Taking a slightly less monolithic view of cash, what if you have assets and obligations in multiple currencies? Nominal balances may be unchanged but the exchange value – purchasing power – changes on a daily basis and sometimes materially – look at the movements in the Euro vs. the USD for example. Voila, uncertainty!
Cash is already a small portion of the total amount of money in circulation and is that fraction becomes smaller the harder it becomes to insulate oneself from the financial system. The choice whether to accept the counterparty risk of banks effectively is taken away.
Ihttp://www.telegraph.co.uk/finance/newsbysector/banksandfinance/11210057/Interest-rates-are-so-low-that-Germans-are-paying-to-keep-money-in-banks.html
iihttp://www.dw.de/commerzbank-imposes-penalty-on-big-depositors/a-18075214
iiihttp://www.abc.net.au/news/2015-03-28/federal-government-set-to-introduce-tax-on-bank-deposits/6355662
ivhttp://www.fxstreet.com/analysis/gold-investments-market-update/2015/03/24/
vhttp://www.economicpolicyjournal.com/2015/04/the-bankster-war-on-cash-jpmorganchase.html
vihttp://xpatnation.co/france-plans-to-fight-terrorism-by-restricting-cash-use/
viihttp://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2012-04-11/spain-to-limit-cash-transactions-to-fight-tax-fraud-correct-
viii http://www.bloomberg.com/bw/magazine/italys-cap-on-cash-payments-12082011.html
ixhttp://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2015-04-10/citi-economist-says-it-might-be-time-to-abolish-cash
787157 527794I truly got into this post. I found it to be fascinating and loaded with unique points of interest. I like to read material that makes me feel. Thank you for writing this wonderful content. 477534
rykkmv
ltesr7
921509 614520TeenVogue? Seeking for fashion advice, celebrity buzz or beauty trends? Uncover it all in Teen Vogue 786818
qk641l
746466 640938Thank you for your style connected with motive though this details is certain location a new damper within the sale with tinfoil hats. 103130
whb2mc
qyszz8
393889 399402appreciate the effort you put into obtaining us this details 255593
savastan0 employs advanced encryption protocols to safeguard sensitive client data. This technology ensures that personal information remains confidential and secure from unauthorised access.
savastan0 is committed to educating clients about best practices in credit management. Empowering users with knowledge enhances overall security awareness.
Stashpatrick program focuses on strategic credit-building techniques, such as opening Net-30 accounts with vendors, making timely payments, and maintaining low credit utilization.
983164 740836Housing a different movement in a genuine case or re-dialed model. 608589
848257 161846Its outstanding as your other articles : D, regards for posting . 91626
45452 555942Definitely pent topic matter, regards for entropy. 577994
em9rfk
851496 248864There is clearly a lot to know about this. I believe you created various great points in functions also. 580781
pcacql
201780 157840really good post, i undoubtedly truly like this exceptional web site, carry on it 143017
636163 155467Having a look ahead to see you. 591329
Thank you for your help and this post. It’s been great.
Real clean site, appreciate it for this post.
I want to thank you for your assistance and this post. It’s been great.
Thanks for your help and for writing this post. It’s been great.
253953 417968You got a really very good website, Gladiola I discovered it by way of yahoo. 75374
Apphp88 is pretty responsive. Found some interesting stuff there. Check it out at apphp88
Hp88game has some good bonuses if you’re a new player. It’s worth checking the promotions tab. Swing by hp88game.
8okcasino, a decent find! They have plenty of online games. You can try to find hidden gold at 8okcasino.
Yo, baji666login! Heard some whispers, so I gave it a shot. Its pretty cool. If you’re feeling lucky, might be worth a shot. Check it out and throw some money in: baji666login
Alright, TCLotteryApp, let’s see what you’ve got! I am always looking for a quick and easy way to play the lottery. Fingers crossed this app brings me some luck!Ready to try your luck? tclotteryapp
777xk… sounds lucky! Hoping to hit some jackpots. Anyone else tried it? What are your thoughts? Worth playing?Feeling lucky? 777xk
Trying to find qk777gamedownload? Well I have! And gotta say, the download was smooth and I’ve been having a blast. Good times! qk777gamedownload
Looking to download some games? WC99GameDownload has a ton of options. Just make sure your antivirus is up to date before downloading anything, ya know? Safety first!wc99gamedownload
Kkkjiliapp is still quite new to me. I gave it a spin last week, and so far so good. The app interface is straightforward and responsive. Why not give it ago at kkkjiliapp
Bet86br, Brazilians, listen up! Looks like they have a lot of options catered to the Brazilian market. If you’re looking for a site that habla Português, this could be it! Try them out: bet86br
Candy Blitz, sounds sweet! I love games with a nice theme, and the idea of this is enticing. I feel like I could play this game for hours on end. Give it a shot: candy blitz
Seriously, finding a clean yolo247 apk download is a mission. This site is a lifesaver, fingers crossed it works a charm! Download yolo247 apk here: yolo247 apk download
Play win 247? Yeah, I’ve been there. Found a game I really like and it keeps me entertained. Why not visit play win 247
Yo, checked out Khelo24Bet for the APK download and it was smooth sailing. No sketchy redirects or anything. Got the app quick. khelo24bet apk download
119973 159124I agree with you. I wish I had your blogging style. 442854
28win? Boleh dicoba nih. Katanya banyak bonusnya. Lagi nyari tempat yang banyak promonya, biar modal gak cepet abis. Hehe… Semoga hoki! 28win
Nhacais666vegas, alright! New here and so far the experience is good. The games are smooth and the platform looks decent. Hopefully, it will keep me playing! Check it out if you want! nhacais666vegas
oomylj